Best Pillow Top Innerspring Mattresses: 5 Top Picks
Five Queen pillow top innerspring mattresses compared on comfort layers, coil design and trial terms. Each pick lists who should skip it.
A pillow top adds a plush layer over the coil core, which suits sleepers who want a softer surface than a flat tight top. This guide compares five Queen pillow top and plush innerspring mattresses, using the details in each product listing.
It is based on listing details and published guidance, not personal use. Plush layers can compress over time, so check the warranty and trial before you buy.
Our top picks
| Award | Product | PomfySleep Score About PomfySleep ScoreThe PomfySleep Score is our own rating from 0 to 10, based on performance, design and build, ease of use, and value. It reflects independent research and is never influenced by manufacturers, retailers, or affiliate commissions. Learn more › | Price | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Sealy Posturepedic® Pro Haverford 15" Medium
|
$1,034.00 | Buy | ||
Serta Perfect Sleeper Enhanced 14.5" Queen
|
$651.74 | Buy | ||
Beautyrest World Class Level Three Plush Pillow
|
$1,499.00 | Buy | ||
Serta Perfect Sleeper Port Townsend 12.5" Plush
|
$699.00 | Buy | ||
Vibe Quilted Hybrid Mattress
|
$399.99 | Buy |
Sealy Posturepedic® Pro Haverford 15" Medium
Serta Perfect Sleeper Enhanced 14.5" Queen
Beautyrest World Class Level Three Plush Pillow
Serta Perfect Sleeper Port Townsend 12.5" Plush
Vibe Quilted Hybrid Mattress
Deeper dive: our top picks
#1 Sealy Posturepedic Pro Haverford 15 Inch Mattress (Queen, Medium Pillowtop)
Why we picked it
Sealy lists MaxSupport Technology, encased coils, a cool-to-the-touch cover and a DuraFlex coil edge under a medium pillowtop.
Who it’s for
Shoppers who want a medium pillowtop with a cooling cover.
- Hot sleepers: A cool-to-the-touch cover is listed.
- Light sleepers: The listing describes encased coils that reduce motion transfer.
- Adjustable base owners: The listing describes a coil edge that suits adjustable bases.
Skip it if you want a lighter bed, since it weighs about 108 pounds, or trial or certification details.
Specs
| Size | Queen |
|---|---|
| Dimensions | 79 x 60 x 15 inches (listed) |
| Feel | Medium pillowtop |
| Construction | PrecisionFit encased coils, MaxSupport Technology (per the listing) |
| Weight | About 108 pounds |
#2 Serta Perfect Sleeper Enhanced 14.5 Inch Mattress (Queen, Plush Pillow Top)
Why we picked it
Serta lists PillowSoft Aire foam, a gel memory foam band for lumbar support, an 825-coil system and cool twist gel memory foam, with a 100-night trial and 10-year warranty.
Who it’s for
Side sleepers who want a plush pillow top with lumbar support.
- Plush-feel fans: The model name and listing describe a plush pillow top.
- Back-support seekers: A gel band for the lower back and hips is listed.
- Trial-minded buyers: A 100-night trial is listed.
Skip it if you want a firm bed, or weight and delivery detail, since the listing gives neither.
Specs
| Size | Queen |
|---|---|
| Dimensions | 79.5 x 60 x 14.5 inches (listed) |
| Feel | Plush pillow top |
| Construction | 825-coil system, PillowSoft Aire foam, gel memory foam (per the listing) |
| Certification | CertiPUR-US (per the listing) |
| Trial and warranty | 100 nights, 10 years (per the listing) |
#3 Beautyrest World Class Level Three Plush Pillow Top 16 Inch Mattress (Queen)
Why we picked it
Beautyrest lists InfiniCool MAX cooling, 1000-density pocketed coils and a soft-yet-supportive plush pillow top feel on a 16-inch bed.
Who it’s for
Shoppers who want the thickest, plushest bed in this set and have delivery help.
- Plush-feel fans: The listing describes a plush pillow top feel.
- Hot sleepers: InfiniCool MAX technology is listed.
- Trial-minded buyers: A 100-night trial and 10-year warranty are listed.
Skip it if you do not want help moving it, since it ships full-size and weighs about 114 pounds, or if you want the lowest price.
Specs
| Size | Queen |
|---|---|
| Dimensions | 79.5 x 60 x 16 inches (listed) |
| Feel | Plush pillow top |
| Construction | 1000-density pocketed coils, high-density foams (per the listing) |
| Certification | CertiPUR-US (per the listing) |
| Weight | About 114.2 pounds |
| Trial and warranty | 100 nights, 10 years (per the listing) |
#4 Serta Perfect Sleeper Port Townsend 12.5 Inch Mattress (Queen, Plush)
Why we picked it
Serta lists a plush feel the listing calls great for side sleepers, with a five-zone design, 4-in-1 coils and PillowSoft Aire foam on a 12.5-inch bed.
Who it’s for
Side sleepers who want a plush bed in a thinner profile.
- Side sleepers: The listing names side sleepers for the plush feel.
- Lighter-bed shoppers: It weighs about 66.6 pounds.
- Trial-minded buyers: A 100-night trial is listed.
Skip it if you want a thick pillow top, since it measures 12.5 inches, or a firm bed.
Specs
| Size | Queen |
|---|---|
| Dimensions | 79.5 x 60 x 12.5 inches (listed) |
| Feel | Plush |
| Construction | Five-zone 4-in-1 coils, PillowSoft Aire foam (per the listing) |
| Certification | CertiPUR-US (per the listing) |
| Weight | About 66.6 pounds |
| Trial and warranty | 100 nights, 10 years (per the listing) |
#5 Vibe Quilted 12 Inch Innerspring and Gel Memory Foam Mattress (Queen, Medium Plush)
Why we picked it
Vibe lists a quilted stretch-knit cover, a 1-inch gel memory foam layer between two 1-inch open-cell foam layers and individually wrapped coils, shipped in a box.
Who it’s for
Shoppers who want a plush pillow top in a bed-in-a-box format.
- Bed-in-a-box shoppers: The listing describes a boxed, compressed delivery.
- Light sleepers: The listing describes wrapped coils that prevent motion disturbance.
- Certification-minded shoppers: CertiPUR-US foam is listed and the bed is described as fiberglass-free.
Skip it if you want a major mattress brand, or a stated trial period, since the listing gives none.
Specs
| Size | Queen |
|---|---|
| Dimensions | 80 x 60 x 12 inches (listed) |
| Feel | Medium plush |
| Construction | Quilted cover, three 1-inch foam layers, wrapped coils (per the listing) |
| Certification | CertiPUR-US (per the listing) |
| Weight | About 89 pounds |
How We Chose These Mattresses
We started from Queen plush and pillow top innerspring mattresses and compared comfort layers, coil design, thickness and trial terms from each listing. Ratings were not available from the listing data, so none are used here. Ratings were not available from the listing data, so none are used here. Our How We Review page explains the approach in full.
How to Choose a Pillow Top Mattress
What a Pillow Top Is
A pillow top is an extra layer of plush material over the main mattress. The Sleep Foundation compares pillow tops with Euro tops, which are sewn flush with the mattress edges.
Durability and Edges
The Sleep Foundation and Mattress Clarity both note that traditional pillow tops can wear faster and may be weaker at the edges, because the plush layer compresses over time. Check layer details and the warranty.
Who They Suit
A pillow top suits people who want a plush surface and do not sit or sleep near the edges much, and its softness can help with pressure relief.
Weight and Delivery
These beds weigh about 67 to 114 pounds, and Beautyrest ships full-size instead of compressed. Plan for help.
Trial and Warranty
Plush layers can soften, so prefer a stated trial and read what the warranty counts as a defect.
Keep reading: our best innerspring mattresses, the innerspring mattresses category and How to Choose an Innerspring Mattress.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does a pillow top mattress last? Published guides say pillow tops generally wear faster than flush tops, and one source puts most at about seven to ten years. It depends on foam density.
Are pillow tops good for side sleepers? Their plush feel can help with pressure relief, which side sleepers often want. Check the thickness of the comfort layer.
Is a pillow top the same as a Euro top? No. A Euro top is sewn flush with the edges, while a traditional pillow top is attached on top. See our comparison guide.
Sources
- Sleep Foundation: Pillow-Top vs. Euro-Top
- Mattress Clarity: What Is a Pillow-Top Mattress?
- Sleep Foundation: Best Innerspring Mattresses
